art
book review

Ways of Seeing - How to appreciate an art piece you don’t understand?

2022-05-12
4 min read
I picked up the book Way of Seeing because I consider myself an idiot to art. When walking into a gallery or art museum, I am always wondering, what makes this drawing so different than others? ...
way of seeing summary


So this is my summary of ways of seeing. (The way of drawing a summary is inspired by Austin Kloen).

Drawing as the fulfilment of desire

I picked up the book Way of Seeing because I consider myself an idiot to art. When walking into a gallery or art museum, I am always wondering, what makes this drawing so different than others? If in front of me is a beautiful woman with perfect shape or a muscular man with iron like outline, I can better than understand why this is a master piece, because it captures the details and everything so perfectly. But if the drawing is about some food lying on the table, then I am sorry, I don’t really find it fascinating.

That is actually normal, because not all the drawing are drawn for art. There are lots of purpose of drawing.

In the book, the author quoted a sentence from the view from Levi-Strauss

It is this avid and ambitious desire to take possession of the object for the benefit of the owner or even of the spectator which seems to me to constitute one of the outstandingly original features of the art of Western civilisation.

Simply put, oil painting created during 1500 - 1900 were for the purpose of satisfying the desire of the collectors (the riches). It is just like camera as we have today, but it couldn’t be copied, so every painting was unique, and therefore precious.

In that sense, I think it is understandable that not everyone can appreciate a piece of drawing. We may be able to understand why is this drawing famous from the context of history, but we may never be able to feel truly the genius of this creation, because the piece of drawing may not be created for and from inspiration or expression of personal feeling.

Camera as the destroyer of meaning of art(?)

Another part of the book that I find especially brilliant is the explanation on how the invention of camera and photos transform the meaning of art. Art works needs to be understood not only from the context of history, but from the environment that is located in. But camera can capture the image of the art as many time as possible, distribute it and place it any where you want. That allows anyone to distort the meaning of the art pieces.

caption of the proccess to calvary

People are rushing to a place. In the crowd, there are normal poor people who travel with their foot, and there are also the riches who are on the horse.

caption of the proccess to calvary

They gathered on a square, where seems to have something happening.

caption of the proccess to calvary

It seems to be something bad, because women are crying and preying.

caption of the proccess to calvary

These drawing are captions from The Procession to Calvary. Although my story isn’t too far from the original meaning of the drawing, you can see that a drawing can be dissected into many different part and turn into a film, which the orders of different matters. If somebody is creative enough, he/ she can turn it into a completely new story.

With camera and limitless image copies of drawing now becomes an information that can be manipulate to distribute any kind of messages.w

writng

How to write articles that people want to read

2022-05-02
3 min read
What is the most important rules for writing? Understand your reader and bring value to them.

What is the most important thing for a writer? Understand who your readers are and what your reader want. It is all about your reader and what value you can provide to your reader.

A while ago, I came across this video on Youtube about effective writing, which is a course in University Chicago. (Link here). The course is for academic writer, but I believe the rules are applicable to every writer that wants to excel.

In the video, Professor McEnerney talked about what actually happened when readers read and writers write and I call it the intersection of reader and writier. Say the reality of writing is that writing is actually a tool for the writer to think. It is the expression of the writer’s idea. And this is, I believe, what most people think. Writing is the tools to show the world your idea, to show the world what does your world looks like.

Writer and reader from different perspective

However, this is not the truth. Reader reads with their own expertise. They read your own article from their own perspective. And this is where the two worlds collide and the result is either they merged into one or the reader simply gives up reading because they don’t understand.

So the first rule of writing, speak the language of your specific reader. You need to understand what words they use and what background they have. Your task as a writer is to help your reader to understand, so that they can absorb what your idea into their own world.

The second rule is to provide value to your reader. To know what your reader want, first we need to understand how does knowledge work in the world. Professor McEnerney points out clearly for us.

This is what we think about knowledge. It is piling up overtime and there is always a foundation where we can reference to and say our new idea is valid because it has a valid foundation.

Knowledge increase with time

But in reality, knowledge is formed in a space, where the people interact and communicate with each other. In other words, knowledge is determine by a specific group of people. They agree on an idea, that idea becomes knowledge.

Expert determines what counts as knowledge

Now that group of people are your specific reader. And what do they want? They want to hear something they don’t know yet and solve their problems. That’s what keep them reading, because it solves their problem. This is value.

Now on effective writing, there are only 2 rules —

  1. speak the language of your reader, so they can understand you
  2. solve your readers problem
avatar
WT Shek
Developer, Creator, Aspire to inspire
This is my blog where I share my knowledge, my learning and my thought. I hope to let other knows me as a person, but not merely a developer, or whatever label being put on me.